
West Virginia’s Republican State Auditor Mark Hunt was indicted on nine theft counts and a bank fraud count, because prosecutors say he signed nine tax deeds over to a lawyer friend after his own staff told him they could not legally be issued.
Story Highlights
- A federal grand jury indicted State Auditor Mark Hunt on nine counts of theft of property.
- Prosecutors say career staff found the nine properties ineligible for deeds, and Hunt signed them anyway.
- The friend, Robert Lisle Johns, was hired as full-time special counsel in the auditor’s office in June 2025.
- Hunt says he is innocent and will fight the charges.
On Monday, November 16, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of West Virginia announced that a federal grand jury had indicted Hunt, 66, of Charleston. A tax deed is the paper that hands a property to a buyer when the owner has not paid property taxes. Prosecutors say Hunt signed deeds for nine properties in Kanawha and Boone counties to a business linked to Johns, his longtime friend and business associate, and that this took the properties from their lawful owners. Hunt is accused, not convicted, and is presumed innocent.
Hunt denies the charges. In a social media post he wrote, “I am innocent of these charges,” said an indictment is only an allegation, and said he will defend himself vigorously.
What Prosecutors Say About The Nine Properties
Prosecutors say career employees in the auditor’s Land Division found all nine properties legally ineligible for deeds, because the buyer missed required payments and paperwork deadlines. Hunt took office in January 2025. They say he signed deeds for eight properties on March 28, 2025, and for a ninth on June 6, 2025, over his staff’s objections.
Prosecutors also say Johns was hired as full-time special counsel in June 2025, after the first eight deeds were issued. Johns and two top aides, general counsel Frederic Scott Caudill and deputy chief of staff David Keith Cole, are also charged with theft in the deed case.
The Bank Fraud Count
The bank fraud charge is a separate matter from the deeds. Prosecutors say an office employee, Marie Ann Hoffmann, turned in false timecards for hours she worked at Hunt’s private law firm, and was paid state wages for that time with Hunt’s knowledge. The pay allegedly came from the state Treasury through its bank. Hunt and Cole are charged in that count with aiding the scheme. Caudill and Cole are also accused of lying to FBI agents.
If convicted, Hunt could face up to 10 years in prison on each theft count and up to 30 years on bank fraud. U.S. Attorney Moore Capito said public officials “are entrusted to serve the people, not use their offices for personal benefit.”
What Happens Next
Hunt is set for an initial appearance and arraignment, where he will enter a plea, at 2 p.m. on November 30 before U.S. Magistrate Judge Dwane Tinsley. Gov. Patrick Morrisey has urged the House of Delegates to consider impeachment as soon as possible. The state Republican and Democratic parties, the House Speaker and the state Treasurer have called on Hunt to resign. Hunt has said he is staying focused on the auditor’s office.
Sources:
redstate.com, justice.gov, wvmetronews.com, wvpublic.org



