Mamdani’s 10 NEW Judge Picks — Look Who SIX Had DEFENDED

Judge slamming gavel on a wooden block
Photo: Denis---S / Shutterstock

Mayor Zohran Mamdani named 10 new city judges, six of them former public defenders, and he says the picks reflect his push for “a judiciary that treats every New Yorker fairly.”

Story Snapshot

  • Mamdani named 10 new judges and reappointed six sitting judges to the city’s Criminal and Family Courts on Monday, November 16.
  • Six of the 10 new judges worked as public defenders, according to reports, including a senior homicide lawyer at Brooklyn Defender Services.
  • The picks came through the mayor’s judicial screening committee, which drew criticism this summer from Jewish lawyers’ groups because it had no Jewish members.
  • Mamdani said religion played no part in choosing that committee, and in October he named a Jewish lawyer to run it.

Mamdani Names 16 Judges for City Courts

On Monday, November 16, Mayor Zohran Mamdani named 10 new judges and reappointed six others to New York City’s Criminal and Family Courts. Mamdani gave his reason in a statement: “The decisions made in our courts can change the course of a New Yorker’s life. That is why the people entrusted with serving on the bench must bring the highest standards of fairness, integrity and accountability to their work.” He added that the 16 judges “reflect our commitment to a judiciary that treats every New Yorker fairly.”

Reports describe the slate as keeping an earlier promise to widen the kinds of legal careers found on the city’s bench. Six of the 10 new judges spent time as public defenders, the lawyers who represent people charged with crimes who cannot afford their own attorney. Ramzi Kassem, the mayor’s chief counsel, said the judges “underwent an extensive vetting process” and “reflect the diversity of the legal profession and the city at large.” The picks were set for a public hearing on Tuesday, November 17, before the judges take the bench.

Who the New Judges Are

The backgrounds below come from City Hall’s announcement of the appointments.

Five new judges go to Criminal Court, which handles lower-level crimes and the first stages of felony cases. Molly Gallivan is a senior homicide attorney at Brooklyn Defender Services, a public defender group, and earlier worked at the Legal Aid Society. William Kendall is a supervising attorney at the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, another public defender group. Alexis Flyer is a principal court attorney in Brooklyn’s Supreme Court and spent nine years at Legal Aid’s criminal defense practice. Two come from the prosecution side: Hana Kim, who has spent more than 15 years in the Queens District Attorney’s Office and leads its Financial Frauds Bureau, and Melissa Medilien, a lawyer for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority who spent six years as a Queens prosecutor.

Five go to Family Court, which handles custody, child welfare and abuse cases. Mary Cheng is a former co-director of the Children’s Law Center and began as a public defender in Maryland. Brian Holbrook is a senior attorney in Brooklyn Defender Services’ family defense practice. Beth Krause supervises Legal Aid’s Immigration Law Unit. Deana Tietjen is deputy executive director of the Children’s Law Center. Danielle Rodriguez served nearly a decade as a court attorney-referee in Family Court.

The six reappointed judges include Tamiko Amaker, the administrative judge of the city’s Criminal Court, who was first appointed by Mayor Michael Bloomberg, and Joseph Sorrentino, a Bronx Criminal Court judge first appointed by Mayor Eric Adams.

How New York City Picks Its Judges

New York City’s mayor alone appoints judges to the Criminal and Family Courts, and fills short-term openings in Civil Court. The mayor chooses from names sent up by the Mayor’s Advisory Committee on the Judiciary, a screening panel that Mayor Ed Koch created in 1978 to cut down on political favors in judge picks. City Hall said all 16 of Monday’s picks were recommended by that committee.

In January, Mamdani signed an executive order rewriting the committee’s rules, and he named Ali Najmi, a Queens lawyer and close ally who had served as his election lawyer, to chair it. This summer the mayor, the state’s chief judge and other court leaders filled the 18-member panel. The committee has since adopted a public code of conduct, and the city gave the New York City Bar Association a formal role in reviewing candidates. Najmi said the committee “worked hard to identify and recommend highly qualified candidates” and that “New Yorkers deserve a fair and effective court system.”

The Criticism Over the Committee and the Mayor’s Response

After the 18 members were named, four Jewish lawyers’ groups wrote to Mamdani in late July to protest that the panel had no Jewish members. Their letter said, “Not a single Jewish attorney, former judge, or legal professional was appointed.” The groups said the omission left them feeling “marginalized.”

Mamdani answered days later. He said religion played no part in choosing the committee, adding, “I think the suggestion that there would be any decision-making motivated by religion, it does bother me.” He pointed to Jewish judges he had appointed earlier in the year and said that “will continue.” In October, he named Douglas Keith, who is Jewish, as the committee’s executive director, the staff leader who runs its day-to-day work.

For readers who care about public safety, the real test is how these judges rule on bail, plea deals and child safety orders. The mayor says his picks will treat every New Yorker fairly, and the record they build in the courtroom is what voters can hold him to.

Sources:

queenseagle.com, nyc.gov, queenseagle.com, nyc.gov, nyc.gov, nydailynews.com