Trump LOST Twice In Court — But WON Where It COUNTED

Donald Trump speaking at a podium with American flags and a ship in the background
Photo: Rawpixel.com / Shutterstock

Trump’s shutdown of asylum at the southern border stays in force while the Supreme Court decides if it is legal, even though two lower courts have ruled against it.

Story Highlights

  • The Supreme Court agreed to hear the fight over Trump’s border asylum shutdown.
  • A federal judge and a divided appeals panel both found the policy unlawful.
  • The appeals court put its own ruling on hold, so agents keep using the policy until the justices rule.
  • A decision is expected by the end of June or early July.

Why the Policy Is Still Running

On Friday, November 13, the Supreme Court said it will decide whether President Trump can shut off asylum for migrants who cross the southern border between official crossings. Asylum is legal protection for people who fear harm or persecution in their home country. Two lower courts have called the policy unlawful. But the appeals court agreed to put its ruling on hold while the government appeals, so border agents can keep using it until the justices decide.

That means the rules at the border stay the same for months. Migrants caught crossing between ports of entry, the official border stations where people are supposed to cross, can be sent back without the chance to apply for asylum. Immigration officials have used the policy for that kind of fast removal since it began.

What Trump Ordered and Why

Trump signed the order on January 20, 2025, his first day back in office. It declares that “an invasion is ongoing at the southern border.” It suspends entry for people crossing between ports of entry and bars them from asking for asylum and similar protections. The Department of Homeland Security then issued guidance saying such migrants could be removed quickly, without some steps the law normally requires.

The administration says the president has the power to keep out people whose entry would harm the country. Solicitor General D. John Sauer, the government’s top lawyer at the Supreme Court, told the justices that the border “had become overwhelmed by an ungovernable influx of millions of aliens.” He said the order “rests on a commonsense understanding of the President’s inherent and delegated powers to exclude aliens.” He has called the policy Trump’s “main tool” for stopping illegal crossings.

How the Lower Courts Ruled

Thirteen migrants and three immigration groups sued in February 2025. The migrants say they fled persecution or torture in their home countries. U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss in Washington ruled that neither the Constitution nor federal immigration law lets the president replace rules that Congress wrote. He also said the president cannot, on his own, limit a person’s right to apply for asylum. Moss applied his ruling to everyone covered by the order.

On April 24, 2026, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit largely agreed, by a 2-1 vote. Judge J. Michelle Childs, joined by Judge Cornelia Pillard, wrote that the order and the guidance go too far where they get around the removal steps Congress set. Judge Justin Walker disagreed in part.

What Each Side Says

The challengers are led by the American Civil Liberties Union. “The president does not have the right to unilaterally override the protections Congress has afforded those fleeing danger,” said Lee Gelernt, the ACLU lawyer leading the case. The challengers also say border arrests had already fallen more than 90 percent from their peak by January 2025, before the order took effect.

The justices will look at whether the order and the guidance are legal. They will also decide whether Judge Moss had the power to apply his ruling to every migrant covered by the order, not only those who sued. Arguments are likely in the spring. The Court is also weighing two other immigration cases: sending migrants to third countries, and holding immigrants without a bond hearing.

Sources:

cbsnews.com, scotusblog.com, newsnationnow.com, law.justia.com, apnews.com