Trump BOXED IN By Supreme Court — The Line He Can’t Cross

Marble columns and steps of a neoclassical building
Photo: Dan Thornberg / Shutterstock

The Supreme Court left Trump unable, for the moment, to claw back about $59 million in research grants already awarded to University of California scientists, because lower courts found the cuts likely punished the researchers’ views.

Story Highlights

  • The Supreme Court refused to hear Trump’s appeal, and no justice publicly dissented.
  • University of California researchers keep about $59 million left on their science and humanities grants while the case goes on.
  • The ruling left in place says Trump may choose which programs to fund, but may not cancel single grants over the views of the people doing the work.
  • The Justice Department warned that the ruling lets taxpayer money fund research that promotes DEI, short for diversity, equity and inclusion.

What The Ruling Means For Trump’s Power Over Grants

On Monday, November 16, the Supreme Court turned down the Trump administration’s appeal in a case called Trump v. Thakur. The justices gave no reason, which is common when the Court declines a case, and no justice publicly dissented. That leaves in place a ruling from the Ninth Circuit, the federal appeals court for California and other Western states. It found that the grant cuts likely violated the First Amendment, the part of the Constitution that protects free speech, because they punished researchers for their views.

The ruling draws a line that matters for every future fight over federal grants. The appeals court said the administration “has not merely exercised its power to choose the programs it funds.” Instead, it said, agencies cut individual grants based on the perceived views of individual researchers. Under that reasoning, a president can still decide which kinds of programs get money going forward. What he likely cannot do is pull money from a grant already awarded because he dislikes what the researcher seems to believe.

The refusal is not a final ruling on the Constitution. It does not set a new rule for the whole country, and the lawsuit goes on in the lower courts. Claudia Polsky, a Berkeley law professor who organized the researchers’ lawsuit, said other courts are “not technically bound by anything. But I think they will find it quite persuasive.” She said she does not expect the White House to appeal again.

Who Keeps The Money

The grants at issue came from the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities, two federal agencies that fund research. The administration says about $59 million remains on them, and some run as late as November 2029. A separate set of grants from the Environmental Protection Agency was settled earlier and is no longer part of the fight.

The cuts were much bigger than this one case. Lawyers for the University of California said the administration cut more than $324 million in grants to the university system from January to June 2025. The grants were ended under executive orders Trump signed early in his second term. Those orders told agencies to cancel grants on certain topics, including DEI programs. Letters ending the grants went out in April 2025, and six UC researchers sued. Polsky said the decision also helps California State University professors who sued in October over their own science grant cuts.

The Administration’s Case For Cutting The Grants

The Justice Department argued that the government has broad power to decide which research deserves taxpayer money. It said a change in priorities can justify ending support for projects that no longer fit those priorities. It also argued that ending a grant does not silence anyone, because researchers are free to seek private money for their work. The department warned that letting the appeals court ruling stand would open the way for taxpayer money to fund research projects that promote DEI.

The researchers tell a different story. Their lawyers say agencies searched grant applications for words like “diversity,” “climate change” and “gender ideology,” then canceled the awards that used them. They argued that once a grant is awarded, scientists should be able to finish the work no matter who is president. Otherwise, they said, any project that runs into a new president’s term could be cut off early.

What Comes Next

U.S. District Judge Rita Lin, the federal trial judge in California who first heard the case, ordered the grants restored in June 2025. She found that the agencies had ended them in bulk, and that the money was likely cut because of the views expressed in the research. The Ninth Circuit upheld her order in May 2026. Her order stays in force while the case goes forward.

For taxpayers and voters, the result sets clear terms for the next round. The White House keeps its power to set grant rules and pick programs before money goes out. But canceling grants already awarded, based on the views a researcher seems to hold, is likely to keep failing in court. The researchers’ lawyers also have a separate challenge in a lower court over grants cut by the Department of Energy, a case that is not part of the Supreme Court’s decision.

Sources:

cbsnews.com, laist.com, law.justia.com