Jail ‘Suicide’ Was MURDER? Expert Points To His Neck

Empty prison cell with light beams through a small barred window
Photo: Boxyray / Shutterstock

A forensic expert says Jeffrey Epstein’s injuries point to homicide, not the suicide that New York City’s medical examiner ruled in 2019.

Story Highlights

  • Forensic scientist Michael Freeman presented his findings in London on Monday, November 16.
  • He says fingernail marks above the neck wound, a deep shoulder bleed and blows to the face fit strangulation from behind.
  • New York City’s medical examiner’s office says it “stands by its determination” of suicide by hanging.
  • Barbara Sampson, the chief medical examiner who ruled the death a suicide, has said she stands firmly behind that ruling.

Expert Says the Injuries Do Not Match a Hanging

On Monday, November 16, forensic scientist Michael Freeman told a London audience that Epstein was more likely strangled from behind than that he hanged himself. He says the marks on the body and the way it was found “don’t match up.” Freeman edits the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine and studies errors in death investigations. He presented at the Middle Temple, a London legal society, after University College London canceled the talk the day before. He also laid out his case in a TV interview.

Freeman reviewed the city medical examiner’s file and autopsy photos. Epstein’s brother, Mark Epstein, gave him the file in November 2025. Freeman says he was not paid by Mark Epstein. He did not see the body himself. He worked with Anders Eriksson, a forensic pathologist in Sweden, and Itiel Dror, who studies bias in forensic work.

The Marks Freeman Points To

Freeman points to what he says are fingernail marks above the ligature mark. A ligature is the cord or cloth around the neck. He says those marks fit a person trying to pull a cord away while being choked. He also cites a deep, fresh bleed in the left shoulder muscle and injuries that look like blows to the face. He said the evidence is “most consistent with an assault, a ligature strangulation from behind.” He believes the same cord was then used to hang the body from a bunk bed.

Freeman also faulted investigators for not testing Epstein’s fingernails for DNA. That test could have shown whether someone else’s skin was under them. Asked who might have killed Epstein, Freeman said he had “no idea.” His work has not passed peer review, the check by other experts that journals use before they publish a study. One journal turned it down, and he plans to submit it again.

Medical Examiner Stands by Suicide Ruling

New York City’s Office of Chief Medical Examiner said on Monday, November 16, that it “stands by its determination.” Its ruling reads: “Cause of death: Hanging. Manner of death: Suicide.” Barbara Sampson was the city’s chief medical examiner at the time and made that ruling. She has said, “I stand firmly behind our determination of the cause and manner of death.”

Kristin Roman, the doctor who did the autopsy and has since retired, told federal investigators the injuries fit suicide by hanging more than strangulation. She found no defensive wounds, the marks people usually get while fighting off an attacker. There were no marks on the hands, no debris under the fingernails and no bruised knuckles. Other forensic pathologists who have seen some of the photos agree the neck mark is unusual for a hanging. Some of them say it could still fit a suicide, and that the injuries alone cannot settle how he died.

Jail Failures the Night Epstein Died

Epstein was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan on August 10, 2019. He was awaiting trial on federal trafficking charges. In 2023, the Justice Department’s inspector general, the agency’s internal watchdog, reported serious failures at the jail. Guards did not make their required 30-minute rounds after about 10:40 p.m. the night before, and required inmate counts were skipped. Cameras near his cell did not record.

The inspector general also said it found no evidence that went against the FBI’s finding that no crime was involved in the death. The jail failures do not prove a killing. But they left no guard and no camera to show what happened in the cell that night.

What Happens Next

Freeman has published his research along with the medical examiner’s files. Autopsy photos were posted online shortly before his talk. Mark Epstein, who has long disputed the suicide finding, said other experts he showed the files to did not reach a firm answer. The medical examiner’s office has not changed its ruling. The official record still lists Epstein’s death as a suicide, and Freeman’s homicide finding is his own expert view.

Sources:

mediaite.com, cbsnews.com, newsweek.com, inquirer.com, wisn.com, oig.justice.gov