INSANE: What A Judge Gave The Gunman Who Shot A Boy

Judge's hand holding a gavel over a sound block
Photo: Freedomz / Shutterstock

A D.C. judge gave probation to a 19-year-old who fired more than 20 shots and hit a boy playing basketball, using a city youth law to skip the five years in prison that prosecutors wanted, and the White House calls it “insanity.”

Story Highlights

  • Darius Drew, 19, fired more than 20 rounds in Northwest D.C. and hit a boy playing basketball at a recreation center, prosecutors say.
  • Prosecutors asked for five years in prison. The judge gave him 18 months of supervised probation instead.
  • The judge sentenced him under D.C.’s Youth Rehabilitation Act, a law that lets judges go easier on offenders under 25.
  • A White House spokeswoman said the case shows the “insanity” of D.C.’s “soft-on-crime policies.”

What Happened In The D.C. Shooting Case

On Friday, November 13, D.C. Superior Court Judge Jennifer Di Toro sentenced Darius Drew, 19, to probation for shooting a boy who was playing basketball at a Northwest D.C. recreation center. She gave him a two-year prison term, then suspended it, which means he does not have to serve it unless he breaks the rules of his release. Instead, he got 18 months of supervised probation. The judge did this under the city’s Youth Rehabilitation Act, a law that lets judges give lighter sentences to people who were under 25 when they committed a crime. Prosecutors had asked for five years in prison, the top of the sentencing range, and objected to using the youth law.

The shooting happened on May 11. According to federal prosecutors, Drew rode a Lime rental bike into an alley near the 700 block of Taylor Street NW and fired at a parked car. ShotSpotter, a system that picks up the sound of gunfire, counted ten shots. Seconds later, prosecutors say, he fired toward a house near the alley, and a bullet hit the boy in the leg at the nearby rec center. In all, prosecutors say he fired more than 20 rounds from two spots. Police arrested him on May 22 and found two guns, ammunition and suspected drugs at his home. On August 10, he pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and carrying a pistol without a license. He had spent nearly six months in jail and was released on the day he was sentenced.

White House Reaction And The Public Safety Argument

White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis said the case “illustrates the insanity of Washington, D.C.’s soft-on-crime policies that allow adults to receive just a slap on the wrist for dangerous crimes like firing twenty rounds of ammunition into the community.” She said the Safe and Beautiful Task Force, the White House’s crime effort in the capital, has helped drive down violent crime despite what she called the city’s “radical policies.” The White House says the task force has made more than 19,000 arrests.

Reporters reached out to Judge Di Toro’s office and the D.C. Council for comment. Neither had made a public response. In D.C., the U.S. Attorney’s Office, the federal prosecutor, handles local crimes too. That office, led by U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro, said prosecutors called Drew’s shooting “indiscriminate” and argued he belonged in prison. The office also opposed releasing him before sentencing.

What The Youth Rehabilitation Act Allows

The Youth Rehabilitation Act covers people who were under 25 at the time of their crime. The D.C. Council expanded it in 2018. Under the law, a judge may go below a mandatory minimum, which is the lowest sentence a law normally requires. A person who finishes the sentence may also get the conviction set aside, which means it can be cleared from his record. Murder and the most serious sexual abuse crimes are not covered.

The law says its goal is to “improve public safety by facilitating rehabilitation and preventing recidivism,” which means helping young offenders change so they do not commit new crimes. Supporters say young adults can still turn their lives around and judges need room to give them that chance. City reports say the law gives courts more sentencing options and the chance to set aside a conviction after the sentence is done.

Accountability, Deterrence, And The Push To Change The Law

Pirro has pushed the D.C. Council to overhaul the law. In an August 2025 letter, she pointed to a different case in which a 19-year-old got probation after shooting someone in the chest on a Metrobus. Her office says 96 percent of defendants under 25 who received felony sentences in D.C. Superior Court from 2022 through 2024 were eligible for the youth law. She argues the law should balance second chances with real accountability.

For critics, the Drew case shows the problem in plain terms. A young man fired more than 20 rounds near a place where children play, and a boy was hit. Prosecutors asked for five years. He walked out of court on probation. The White House says that kind of outcome tells would-be shooters there is little price to pay. For families who want safe parks and basketball courts, the debate over this law is a fight over what happens on their own block.

Sources:

foxnews.com, justice.gov, wjla.com, fox5dc.com, code.dccouncil.gov, cic.dc.gov