Ten Commandments Mandate Shocks Texas Schools

Empty classroom with desks, chairs, windows, and chalkboard.

Texas schools are now mandated to display the Ten Commandments in every classroom, igniting a fierce national debate over religious freedom, constitutional rights, and the future of public education.

Story Snapshot

  • Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton orders public schools to comply with Senate Bill 10, requiring display of the Ten Commandments in classrooms.
  • The law faces federal lawsuits, with implementation blocked in several districts but proceeding in most of the state.
  • Civil liberties groups argue SB 10 violates the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause, setting up a potential Supreme Court battle.
  • Schools must fund displays privately, highlighting disparities and administrative burdens without state financial support.

Texas Mandates Ten Commandments Displays in Public School Classrooms

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has directed all public schools not impacted by current litigation to display the Ten Commandments in every classroom, enforcing Senate Bill 10. Passed by the legislature and signed by Governor Greg Abbott, the law requires a durable, conspicuous poster or framed copy of the Ten Commandments, at least 16 by 20 inches, with language specified by statute. This move is part of a broader effort to embed traditional moral values in education and challenge decades of federal precedent restricting religious displays in public institutions.

Unlike previous mandates, SB 10 prescribes a specific Protestant version of the Ten Commandments and does not allocate state funds for implementation. Instead, schools must rely on private donations to meet the requirements, which could create disparities between districts. The law’s supporters, including Republican lawmakers and faith leaders, contend that the Ten Commandments provide a moral foundation integral to American legal and ethical traditions. However, this claim is contested by both historians and some Christian parents who emphasize religious diversity and parental rights in education.

Legal Challenges and Divided Implementation

Shortly after the bill’s passage, organizations such as the ACLU of Texas, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, and the Freedom From Religion Foundation initiated federal lawsuits to block SB 10. Plaintiffs argue the law violates the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause, which prohibits government endorsement of a particular religion. As a result, federal courts have blocked implementation in at least eleven school districts, while unaffected districts are under strict orders from the Attorney General to comply immediately. This patchwork compliance has created confusion for administrators and uncertainty for families statewide.

Legal experts widely view SB 10 as unconstitutional, referencing the Supreme Court’s 1980 *Stone v. Graham* decision that explicitly barred mandatory Ten Commandments displays in public schools. Despite this, Texas lawmakers have joined a broader conservative trend, seeking to challenge or circumvent federal restrictions and inject religious values into the educational system. The resulting legal uncertainty is likely to escalate, with the potential for a landmark Supreme Court review that could set national precedent for religious expression in public spaces.

Societal and Political Implications for Conservative Values

For many conservatives, SB 10 represents both a victory for traditional values and a test of federal overreach. Proponents argue that restoring the Ten Commandments to classrooms is a step toward reasserting America’s moral roots and countering secular influences in public education. Critics, however, warn that government-mandated religious displays erode parental autonomy and threaten the constitutional separation of church and state, potentially alienating families who do not share the prescribed beliefs.

Economically, the unfunded mandate places increased burdens on local schools, forcing them to seek private donations and navigate administrative hurdles. Socially and politically, SB 10 is intensifying divisions over the role of religion in public life and fueling broader debates about the direction of American education. As legal battles continue, Texas may serve as a template for similar efforts in other states, with implications that could reshape the boundaries between faith, government, and education nationwide.

Sources:

Texas Policy Research: 89th Legislature SB 10

ACLU of Texas: Civil Liberties Groups Will Sue Over Texas Law Requiring Ten Commandments

Texas Tribune: Ten Commandments Texas Schools Senate Bill 10

Texas Tribune: Texas Schools Commandments Requirement Lawsuit

LegiScan: SB 10 Bill Text